Can VA deny my claim for missing a C&P exam under H.R. 9237?
Section 105(a) says VA may not deny a claim 'on the sole basis' that you did not show up for the exam. The word 'sole' does the work. Here's the line and what it leaves open.
By Vegas Veteran Voices,
Section 105(a) says VA may not deny a claim “on the sole basis” that you did not show up for the exam. The word “sole” does the work. Here’s the line and what it leaves open.
By Vegas Veteran Voices
Where it stands, November 16, 2026: the House passed H.R. 9237 by voice vote on November 11, 2026. The Senate has not voted. It is not law, and nothing about your rating, your check or your care has changed because of it. Vegas Veteran Voices takes no side on this bill. This is what it says, and what people on each side say it means. Latest status
The short answer
One sentence in the bill, and it hangs on one word: “sole.”
If the bill becomes law as written, VA could not deny a claim for missing the exam and nothing else. Section 105(a) says VA “may not deny such claim on the sole basis that such Veteran failed to appear for such medical examination.” VA could still deny a claim for some other reason. The bill does not say what VA must do instead.
First, what is a C&P exam
C&P stands for compensation and pension. The exam is an appointment with a doctor or other examiner, VA’s or a contractor’s, who looks at the condition you claimed. VA’s own page says “This exam will help us determine if you have a service-connected disability” (VA, claim exams).
The bill does not use the name C&P. It says “medical examination.” Government does love two names for one thing.
What happens today if you miss one
VA’s page says “We may also decide your claim based on the existing evidence, which could affect your benefits” (VA, claim exams).
The detailed rule is a federal regulation, 38 CFR 3.655. For a first-time compensation claim, paragraph (b) says “the claim shall be rated based on the evidence of record” (Cornell LII, 38 CFR 3.655). The same paragraph sets different results for other kinds of claims, such as increases. We did not work through each type. Read the paragraph, or ask a free accredited service officer.
The law that makes VA offer exams at all is 38 U.S.C. 5103A. Its subsection (d)(1) begins: “In the case of a claim for disability compensation, the assistance provided by the Secretary under subsection (a)” and goes on to say VA’s help includes an exam when one is needed (Cornell LII, 38 U.S.C. 5103A). Section 105(a) of the bill adds its new line to that subsection.
Where to see it in the bill
- Section 105(a). House version: Congressional Record, July 16, 2026, page H4551. Introduced text: page 22, lines 13 to 19, with the section starting on page 21.
- Same in both versions. We compared the two word by word. Section 105(a) does not differ.
What it says
Section 105(a) adds a new paragraph (3) to 38 U.S.C. 5103A(d):
“If a Veteran fails to appear for a medical examination provided by the Secretary in conjunction with a claim for a benefit under a law administered by the Secretary, the Secretary may not deny such claim on the sole basis that such Veteran failed to appear for such medical examination.”
Two small changes sit next to it. The bill changes the heading of subsection (d) from “Compensation claims” to “Claims for benefits,” which matches the wider reach of the new line. It also swaps a few words in paragraph (d)(2). We did not analyze that swap.
What it means
- It reaches past disability compensation. The line covers “a claim for a benefit under a law administered by the Secretary.” That is every kind of VA benefit claim where VA provides an exam.
- “Sole basis” is narrow on purpose. A missed exam can’t be the only reason for a denial. A denial for another reason is still allowed.
- It does not grant anything. Skipping the exam is not an approval. The claim still has to be decided.
- It does not say what happens next. The bill does not say whether VA must reschedule, decide on the evidence already in the file, or something else.
- “Fails to appear” is not defined. The text does not say how a late arrival, a canceled appointment or a rescheduled one would count.
Starting when: the bill states no special date for this line. It would start when and if the bill becomes law, then however VA writes it into its rules. Until then the regulation above is what VA follows.
What you don’t need to worry about: this line does not touch how VA picks examiners or how exams are scheduled. Those are other sections.
Who it helps
Anyone with a claim for a VA benefit that involves a VA-provided exam. The practical size of that group depends on how VA writes its rules around this one sentence.
This line is one piece of a larger set of exam provisions. The rest, on examiner licensing, exam quality reviews and scheduling, are in What does H.R. 9237 change about C&P exams?
Where the bill stands
The House passed H.R. 9237 by voice vote on November 11. Military Times reports The House “passed by voice vote on Veterans Day without a recorded tally of how individual lawmakers voted” (Military Times, November 12). The Senate has not acted. Stars and Stripes reports the bill “was passed unanimously by voice vote at about 2:45 p.m. Wednesday” (Stripes, November 12). A voice vote is a yell of yeas and nays. No names, no count.
What we don’t know yet
- How VA would write this into its rules. The bill sets the sentence. VA’s regulations would set the process, and 38 CFR 3.655 is the place to watch.
- What the Senate does. S. 4744 is the Senate companion; we have not compared its text.
- How this works with VA’s current rules for missed exams. The bill does not restate or repeal them. A free accredited service officer can read your claim. A headline can’t.
The bill does not change today’s exam rules, and it is not law. We are not claims agents and we do not advise on appointments.
Where to go from here
For anything about your own claim, rating or benefits, talk to free accredited help. Listings are not an endorsement.
- Veterans Service Officers, VAST Las Vegas (Nevada Department of Veterans Services). Free, state-employed service officers who help Veterans file and follow VA claims in Las Vegas.
- Find a VA-accredited representative. VA’s own search for free accredited help, by ZIP code.
- H.R. 9237 on Congress.gov. The bill’s official page: text, every action and its status.
If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.
More on H.R. 9237
Start at the full guide to H.R. 9237.
Ratings and claims: Will H.R. 9237 cut sleep apnea ratings? · Will H.R. 9237 cut tinnitus ratings? · I’m already rated. What happens to me under H.R. 9237? · What does the October 1, 2026 date in H.R. 9237 mean for my claim? · Does H.R. 9237 change PTSD or other VA ratings? · Is H.R. 9237 a $57 billion cut to Veterans’ benefits? · What does H.R. 9237 change about VA appeals? · What does H.R. 9237 change about C&P exams? · Will H.R. 9237 make VA letters and forms easier to read? · What does H.R. 9237 change for MST claims?
Money, survivors and home loans: What does H.R. 9237 do with the Major Richard Star Act? · TCAVA’s Star Act vs the standalone Star Act: what’s the difference? · Can surviving spouses remarry without losing benefits under H.R. 9237? · What does H.R. 9237 change for DIC and ALS survivors? · What is the $833.33 a month in H.R. 9237? · Does H.R. 9237 raise VA home loan fees? · Can Guard and Reserve get a VA home loan under H.R. 9237?
School, jobs and getting out: What does H.R. 9237 change about the GI Bill? · Does H.R. 9237 raise GI Bill apprenticeship pay? · What does H.R. 9237 change about TAP and SkillBridge?
Mental health and care: What does H.R. 9237 do to the Fox suicide prevention grants? · What are the mental health care grants in H.R. 9237? · Will H.R. 9237 make it easier to get into VA residential treatment? · Can VA prescribe controlled medications by telehealth under H.R. 9237? · What does H.R. 9237 do about opioid overdoses? · Does H.R. 9237 pay for service dogs? · What does H.R. 9237 do for TBI and blast exposure? · What does H.R. 9237 do for caregivers? · What does H.R. 9237 change about how Veteran deaths are counted? · What does H.R. 9237 do for women Veterans? · What does H.R. 9237 do for Veterans with spinal cord injuries? · What does H.R. 9237 do for prosthetics, adaptive sports and car adaptations? · Does H.R. 9237 study the children of toxic-exposed Veterans?
The VA system: What does H.R. 9237 change about community care? · Does H.R. 9237 privatize the VA? · What does H.R. 9237 do for rural Veterans? · What does H.R. 9237 change for Veterans on VA and Medicare? · Which new VA hospitals are in H.R. 9237? · What does H.R. 9237 mean for VA staff? · Will H.R. 9237 fix VA scheduling and phone calls? · What does H.R. 9237 change for burial benefits and headstones?
The politics: Why are Veteran groups split on H.R. 9237? · Where does H.R. 9237 stand, and what happens next? · Why was H.R. 9237 passed by voice vote?