Is it hard to go from leading troops to working with civilians?
You had a playbook, a chain of command and a rank on your chest. Now you have a team that has not read any of it. Five Veterans on what leading looks like without the uniform.
By Vegas Veteran Voices,
From From 50 Cal Gunner to VA Loan Nerd | Caitlin Duffy’s Veteran Story
You led people. Maybe a fire team, maybe a shop, maybe a few hundred. You knew what a good day looked like because everybody had been trained to the same standard, and when somebody drifted you had options that were not a conversation with HR.
Then you got a civilian job, and your first team meeting felt like walking into a room where someone had changed the language.
We do not have as many Veterans on tape about this one as we do about most questions, and we will not pretend otherwise. In interviews filmed by Vegas Veteran Voices, a Las Vegas nonprofit, five Veterans spoke to it in some depth, and two older interviews add supporting lines. What they say is consistent enough to be worth reading, and it is not a study. For the adjacent subject of how civilians read you, see Why do civilians think I’m aggressive?.
Same playbook, until it isn’t
Caitlin Duffy, a U.S. Army Veteran, led troops, then led civilians. She is funny about it and exact.
“Leading civilians is like herding cats, basically.”
Then the line that explains it.
“In the military, we all had the same playbook, so we always spoke the same language, and leading in civilian is like showing up to football practice where half of them haven’t read the playbook and two of them thought they were showing up to bowling night.”
She calls it difficult for her employment and her leading. Note what she does not say: she does not say the civilians were wrong. The problem is a shared language that is not shared.
Ureal Irving, a U.S. Army Veteran and the founder of Envision Footwear, gave us the older, drier version in one of our earliest interviews, from before we became a nonprofit.
“In the military, you’re results-oriented. You’re like, I don’t care how you get it done, get it done, get it going, get it moving. In the civilian world, it’s like, well, we need to go down our checklist and if we don’t make every single point, then we’re in the wrong and then go talk to HR.”
The voice goes missing too. Brandon Mills, a U.S. Army Veteran, Abrams tank gunner and print shop founder, is also from one of our early interviews. He holds a degree in human resources, which makes him a credible witness to red tape, and he says the voice you used in the Army does not carry over.
“Using your voice, it’s very different in the civilian world. It seems like you always have to be very careful about legal things and emotions.”
He also says a lot of people just do not have the resiliency the military builds in. That is his opinion, said in a conversation, and some civilians would answer back. Both Mills and Irving are supporting voices here. Neither is a lead, since both interviews predate our nonprofit.
Your rank stays at the gate
AJ Kehl, a U.S. Air Force Veteran and career firefighter, put 22 and a half years in and had the big office and the yes-sirs. He is blunt about what happens to authority when the rank goes.
“Your rank has nothing to do with anything, man. Like your character, your integrity would be the only things that go forward.”
That is both a loss and a relief. It means you are going to have to earn the room again. In the Army, Air Force or Marines, someone else gave you the authority. A civilian team gives it to you slowly, if at all.
Jennifer Marshall, a U.S. Navy Veteran who is now an actress and firefighter EMT, was on the receiving end.
“You get out, and then you start going into the civilian world and you’re getting told what to do by people who they just feel like they’re better than you for no reason than your age.”
She did not go into management. She says working for herself was how she managed it.
The thing leaders actually learn
Edward Haines, a retired Marine Master Sergeant who led Radio Battalion, says a leadership lesson he learned in uniform was delegation. It also happens to be one that travels.
“I learned you’re not shifting off the responsibility, but you’re delegating the tasks at hand. And that’s a hard one to figure out when you’re used to holding everything close hold.”
He says it took almost a burnout at Fort Meade to learn it. A civilian job tends to hand you people who can do the work if you stop hovering. His point: knowing everything is not the same as doing everything.
And then what he does with his leadership now.
“My bosses now as an athletic trainer, they’ve tried to talk me into taking on a responsibility role. I’m like, dude, I’m just here to work, man. I’ve had people under me. I’m solid.”
Not everyone wants to go back to being in charge. Haines does not. After twenty years of it, he says he will do the work, follow the company policy, and leave the rest alone.
And the boss you left is out here too
Travis Jewell, a Marine Corps Veteran and 1/6 mortarman, tells a story about a civilian manager that changed how he sees leadership. She told him there are three kinds of leaders.
“There’s people that are natural-born leaders. There’s people that learn how to lead. They learn it through education and seminars and certifications. They learn how to be a leader. And there’s people who just ain’t got it.”
He applied it back to the platoon commander he had left over. He also found that it is not a military problem.
“If anybody gets anything taken away from this, the bad leadership is always going to be there. It’s always going to be there.”
So is it hard?
Yes, and for the reasons they give, it is not the reasons you would guess. It is not that civilians are lazy or that you forgot how to lead. It is that the three things that made leading easy are gone: a shared playbook, an authority that arrives with the rank, and a clear way to correct someone.
What is left is the part that was always the job: people, trust, character. Kehl says character and integrity are what go forward. Haines says the thing to keep is teaching people to do what you do. Duffy says the cats can be herded. Jewell says the bad bosses came with him. Nobody said “easy.”
The Department of Labor says over 200,000 service members transition to civilian life each year, so you are one of a very large number of people having this exact meeting.
Where to go from here
No advice from us. These are places that exist, what each one does and how to reach it.
- Military OneSource: Transitioning Veterans consultation A free Department of Defense service of 45-minute consultations on goals, benefits, VA help, education and civilian careers. Open to anyone within 12 months of separating or within 365 days after the last day of service. 800-342-9647.
- VA Solid Start VA calls newly separated service members around 90, 180 and 365 days out. You can also call: 1-800-827-0611.
- Veterans Career Employment Team (Nevada DETR) A state employment program. Career coaches help Veterans and eligible spouses with career planning, resumes, interview preparation and job search, in person or online.
- Nevada Department of Veterans Services (Las Vegas office) The state agency for Veterans. Connects Nevada Veterans and families to education, housing, employment and health care benefits; its accredited Veterans Service Officers help with VA claims at no cost.
A listing is not an endorsement.
Related questions
If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.
Go hear them say it
Every quote above links to the second it was said, on YouTube. Start with Duffy and the bowling night. Our list of posts, clubs and teams is at Veteran resources in Las Vegas.
Stories quoted in this article
- From 50 Cal Gunner to VA Loan Nerd | Caitlin Duffy’s Veteran Story
- He Listened for 20 Years. Now He Tapes Ankles at a High School.
- Redefining Veteran Healing w/ Shields and Stripes | AJ KEHL
- Every Lance Corporal Is Thinking It. Travis Jewell Says It. (@jewell_jits)
- You’ve Seen Her on Stranger Things. Here’s What Nobody Knew About This Navy Veteran.
- From Iraq to Iconic: The Wild Story Behind Envision Footwear (recorded before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit)
- This Veteran Lived on a Thai Island… Now He Runs a T-Shirt Empire / Brandon Mills Total Promotion Co (recorded before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit)