The title card of the story “Every Marine Asks Where You Deployed. He Hated the Answer. / JMach & Tommy Nutz”

Veterans Say

Is peer support better than therapy for Veterans?

Our guests do not pick. They tell you what each one gave them and where each one fell short. Ten Veterans on the fight that mostly is not one.

By Vegas Veteran Voices,

From Every Marine Asks Where You Deployed. He Hated the Answer. / JMach & Tommy Nutz

Tommy Nutzmann was in therapy through the VA. Then his appointments moved to video.

Tommy Nutzmann, a retired U.S. Navy Chief and the creator of After the Uniform, retired after 20 years and, by his own account, did not know who he was.

“I had appointments that became, like, in person to now virtual. I need somebody to talk to in person.”

Hear it at 36:38

So he went looking for people instead. That is where this article starts, and it is not where it ends.

In interviews filmed by Vegas Veteran Voices, a Las Vegas nonprofit, ten Veterans talked about therapists, peers or both. We are not going to tell you which is better. Several of them did both and say so. What they disagree on is smaller and more interesting: whether the person across from you needs to have been there.

The case for your own kind

Nutzmann did not stop at the video call. He reached out to Veteran health groups and found something he had not had.

“And learning I wasn’t the only one. And then being able to learn different avenues and talking to people who are literally going through the same thing I was going through.”

Hear it at 36:54

He does not claim it solved anything.

“It’s still an uphill battle. Like, I have great days and I have dark days.”

Hear it at 37:09

Jason Lee Morrison, a USMC Veteran, Recon Marine and writer, stayed away from his old unit for years. Then he did not.

“When I finally did, man, it was like recognizing someone I hadn’t met in years and it was me.”

Hear it at 2:17

“Plugging into a Veteran community is probably the first step in trying to make sense of all this stuff.”

Hear it at 2:39

AJ Kehl, a U.S. Air Force Veteran and career firefighter, says the same thing about a room. He was in a program with seven others, put up in a hotel, with a therapist on the schedule every day.

“I’m in a room full of vets and everyone here knows exactly what I’m going through.”

Hear it at 46:23

“The one thing that is going to help out vets more than anything is breaking that isolation and reaching out and discussing what they’re going through with other people.”

Hear it at 46:29

Notice that he is describing peers inside a clinical program. He had never seen a therapist in his life, he says, before that program, and he does not tell the story as peers instead of therapy.

The case for a professional

Not every Veteran needs persuading, and some need no company at all. Randall Parkes, a Marine Corps Veteran, drill instructor and founding MARSOC Raider, started having trouble around year 17 or 18. His wife noticed. A Navy hospital visit did not work out. After he got out, he tried counseling through the VA.

“I know the VA gets a bad rap and rightly so. They’ve earned that reputation. But my experience with the VA on the mental health side has been phenomenal.”

Hear it at 59:34

By his account, it took about 48 hours to get in. For shoulder and back problems he says the VA was something else entirely, and compared it to the DMV. That is his experience, and it is exactly the kind of thing Veterans disagree about.

Travis Jewell, a Marine Corps Veteran and mortarman, resisted therapy for years. When he gave in, what struck him was the person across from him.

“It was like one of the most surreal feeling, like bliss, dude. Just being able to talk to someone that understood where I was coming from based off their experiences.”

Hear it at 47:20

Emilio Mackie, a U.S. Navy Veteran and surface warfare officer, did something specific about that. He used Military OneSource to find a therapist who was trained in working with people leaving the military.

“I actually went through Military OneSource to find a therapist who was specifically trained in transitioning service members.”

Hear it at 4:35

The complaint

Here is the fight. Juan Valdez, a Marine Corps Veteran and Purple Heart recipient who works with Wounded Warrior Project, is blunt about some of the therapists he has met, and fair about them.

“It’s like I’m talking to a wall sometimes, right? And it feels like they say the same things over and over again, which, to be fair, they went to school for this and all that, right?”

Hear it at 44:56

“Being from the deployment that you and I went on, it’s really hard to explain that to somebody who has no experience.”

Hear it at 45:19

Compare that with Jewell, who found a therapist who understood, and Mackie, who went looking for one who was trained. The disagreement is not therapy versus peers. It is whether the person across from you has to share your uniform, or has to share your experience, or just has to be good at the job. Valdez also went through one of the Wounded Warrior Project programs it runs with academic hospitals, and describes what he got out of it.

“I went through that this past February. And it was eye opening, man. I could look myself in the mirror, right? I was able to identify the things that I liked from my past, the things that made me a Marine, things that are still positive and I can bring over.”

Hear it at 50:51

Becoming the peer

Two guests say that the biggest change was being the person someone else could call. Jason Brooks, a medically retired Marine and former Recon and SERE instructor, worked as a peer mentor with Veteran court after a low stretch of his own.

“I was a peer mentor with Veteran court, trying to help people go through stuff. Because I know what it’s like to be there.”

Hear it at 37:20

“It might look like that everything’s closing in on you, but that’s not the reality of the situation. There’s people out there that can help you and people out there that can walk you through it.”

Hear it at 37:31

Jessica Jay Dee, a Marine Corps Gunnery Sergeant and combat Veteran, has done the clinical side and says it took more than that.

“The more that I tried to be helpful to others, the more that I healed.”

Hear it at 19:27

She did the counseling and she did the medication, she says, and nothing about it was a trick. Helping people was what she added. We cannot tell you it would do the same for you.

Why it matters that they are in the same room

Ross D. Bryant, a U.S. Army Veteran who leads UNLV Military and Veteran Services, has watched students in distress. He gives his cell number to every Veteran who comes through his office. He says what ran through the hardest cases at his school.

“Isolated, I wouldn’t say by choice, but isolated and distressed and under high anxiety, usually alcohol involved and this deep despair because they weren’t part of a community.”

Hear it at 40:25

It is one man’s observation from one campus. It is also a reason a campus builds a Veterans group. That is his answer, and it is community, not either of the two things in our headline.

Does VA say it is either-or?

Not that we can find. VA’s mental health page, which we opened on November 16, 2026, says its services range “from peer support with other Veterans to counseling, therapy, medication.” It describes a program called BeThere where you can talk privately with peer coaches who are Veterans, service members or military spouses. Vet Centers, VA’s counseling centers, say many of their counselors and outreach staff are Veterans themselves. VA does not choose between the two. Neither did most of our guests.

What we have not asked

We have not asked anyone who tried peer support and found it was not enough, or who tried a peer group that went badly. We have not asked a therapist who is also a Veteran what it is like to sit on both sides. We would like to.

Where to go from here

No advice from us. These are places that exist, what each one does and how to reach it.

  • Las Vegas Vet Center A VA counseling center that is separate from the hospital. Free, confidential individual, group, couples and family counseling, including for PTSD. 702-791-9170.
  • Henderson Vet Center A VA counseling center in Henderson that offers free confidential counseling, groups and bereavement services in a non-medical setting. 702-791-9100.
  • VA mental health services VA's overview of its mental health care, which it says ranges from peer support with other Veterans to counseling, therapy and medication.
  • Military OneSource A Department of Defense service with a 24-hour phone line and chat offering counseling, coaching and practical help. 800-342-9647. Its eligibility page says who can use it after separation.

A listing is not an endorsement.

Related questions

If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.

Go hear them say it

Every quote above links to the second it was said. Start with Nutzmann and the video call. More places to turn in Southern Nevada are at Veteran resources in Las Vegas. Watch all of it on YouTube.

Stories quoted in this article

DonateFund the next story