Did your recruiter lie to you?
A reserve unit that was never going anywhere. A job that no longer existed. A recruiter who turned out to be great. Eight Veterans on what they were told and what they signed.
By Vegas Veteran Voices,
From Why Do Marines Treat Dark Humor Like Therapy? Michael D’Angelo USMC 0331
Michael D’Angelo wanted out of Las Vegas so badly that he gave up a $10,000 signing bonus to ship 25 days early. His recruiter said yes to everything. A different job? Sure. Reserves? Sure, the unit is at Nellis, and when you check in you just submit your paperwork to go active. The unit deploys to Iraq in April. You will be on it.
He signed. He checked in at Nellis, which is in Las Vegas. Then he asked when they were going to Iraq.
That is one answer to the question you typed. It is not the only one. In interviews filmed by Vegas Veteran Voices, a Las Vegas nonprofit, eight Veterans told us what their recruiters promised and what the paperwork delivered. They do not agree on whether anyone lied. One of them says his recruiter was great. Hold that thought.
The one who was told he was going
Michael D’Angelo is a Marine Corps Veteran, machine gunner and stand-up comic. He joined in 2008. The pitch, in his words:
“He made it seem nice and fluffy.”
The reserve unit, the machine gun job, the promise that he could go active the minute he arrived. When he got to Nellis, he says, the unit had started its work-up for Iraq in November and he was not on the list. He asked to go active, and the room told him no.
“What? My recruiter said.”
Everyone in the room laughed. Then someone explained that he was there because his unit had an open slot.
“You’re billeted here. The reason you’re here is because we have an open billet.”
He was a private first class in a room with a company commander and a first sergeant, and he did the only thing a private first class can do. He wrote to his senator. The senator’s office called Marine Corps headquarters, headquarters called his unit, and his unit chewed him out for it. He did eventually get out of the country, to Belize, and later to Southeast Asia. It just was not the way he was told.
The job that was no longer there
Not every broken promise is a lie. Some of them are a recruiting station running a few weeks behind the Army.
Curtez Riggs, a retired Army First Sergeant and founder of Military Influencer Conference, went to MEPS to be an aeroscout. He had it all pictured: the navigator seat, the little helicopters.
“But the reality was when I got to MEPS, that job was no longer in existence.”
The people at MEPS did not send him home. They offered him cavalry scout, with an airborne option, and he signed at seventeen without a second thought. Looking back, he does not hedge about what happened.
“They sold me hard. Didn’t even realize it.”
He is also the guy who walked out of a Marine recruiter’s office laughing, after the recruiter draped a jacket over his shoulders and asked if he felt like a man, and into the Army office next door. Riggs does not pretend the Army was doing anything different. He says the difference was how it felt.
“And even though now I know I was being sold, his approach was so much gentler, so much kinder, so much more focused on what my values were and what I needed.”
Then he spent 16 and a half years in recruiting command himself, and part of that back in Flint, where he grew up.
“I went back to my hometown to be a recruiter. So like when it came to the military in Flint, I was the representation.”
So the man who was sold hard became the face of the thing being sold. He says the job taught him soft skills years before most people need them. He has sat on both sides of that desk.
Needs of the service
Jason Brooks, a medically retired Marine and former Recon and SERE instructor, went to the Air Force first. He wanted to be a pararescueman. He had scored a 99 on the ASVAB and a checkered history in Vegas that needed waivers. The recruiter offered him a deal.
“You got to come in under general waiver. So, you need to go into needs of the Air Force.”
Which meant aircraft mechanic. He asked to try out for PJ first and go to mechanic if he washed out. The answer was no, so he went to the Marines, where he signed up as a satellite communications operator.
At the end of boot camp an instructor told him his job was NBC. He thought it was a television network. It was chemical warfare defense, and he was supposed to run a gas chamber. The instructor, he says, sent him to a pay phone to call a recruiter. The explanation he got:
“The guy that ran our recruiting station, he messed up on some paperwork because I was supposed to have a bonus and all this stuff.”
The offer on the table, he says, was to void the contract and go home. Brooks had just finished boot camp.
“Go home. Come on, dude. Like, I just made it through boot camp.”
He stayed. His job became, in his words, needs of the Marine Corps. Needs of the Air Force, needs of the Marine Corps. Same phrase, different logo.
The second pitch
Randall Parkes, a Marine Corps Veteran, former drill instructor and founding MARSOC Raider, was offered the Army deal in 2000: his choice of job, his choice of duty station, a $10,000 bonus. He went back to the Marine recruiter to see if he could match it. The recruiter did not negotiate.
“He points to the eagle, globe and anchor and he’s like, ‘Look, man, this is all I can give you.’”
The next line is not printable here, and it worked. Parkes went on to a Marine Corps career. But he also says his recruiter talked him into a job by comparing it to the most elite thing available.
“My recruiter convinced me that going security forces was basically like joining SEAL Team 6, the cops.”
His first assignment, he says, was a command in Bangor, Washington, that does not deploy. It was not the one in the pitch.
Edward Haines, a retired Marine Master Sergeant who spent 20 years in signals intelligence and Radio Recon, got a different version. He had signed an infantry contract. In boot camp, a few recruits with good scores were pulled aside by Marines from the intelligence field, who sat them down with packets.
“He talks it better than my recruiter did.”
“They fill your eyes with wonder and you’re like, ‘Oh, man. This sounds awesome, dude.’”
He says the real answer to where you land is the needs of the Marine Corps. You can have all the skills in the world, he says, and show up as the new guy and be told to go sit in a room and check IDs.
“And so you just show up and they’re like, ‘Well, I need a SCIF guard, so that’s you. Go sit in that room and check IDs.’”
Haines does not call that a lie, and he says he has no regrets about joining. He just says it is how the machine works.
“Cheeks” Aguillon, a U.S. Army Veteran and former chaplain assistant who now serves on the Vegas Veteran Voices board, wanted airborne in his contract. His recruiter, he says, told him they did not really need airborne chaplain assistants, so it could not go in. At AIT, two chaplain assistants from Fort Bragg showed up with a parachute.
“All right, so bottom line is we need as many airborne chaplain assistants as we can get.”
He volunteered on the spot and got a slot at airborne school out of AIT.
And one who was great
Alfred Brenner, a Marine Corps Purple Heart recipient, retired K9 handler and author, saw what an open contract can do to a kid at the moment the jobs are read out.
“I remember one kid, he was with us and he started crying because he told him he was going to corrections because the recruiter gave him open contract in MP.”
Brenner’s own deal went fine.
“But my recruiter was great. He put me in 5811.”
That was military police. Halfway through military police school he volunteered for the K9 selection, partly out of spite after being told he would have to be the best in his class, and calls it the best decision of his life. A recruiter can be honest, and an open contract can still land a kid in the wrong building.
One more, because it is the cleanest version of the thing. Sarah, an Army Reserve staff sergeant and medic who co-owns a Las Vegas restaurant, said in an early episode that she tried to play the branches against each other for the best bonus. Then she says the recruiter played her. She wanted to be a medic. He said the only slot was fueler, and that she could switch once she was in.
“That was a lie. I was the only fueler for our entire battalion.”
She did not leave that spot for six years. (That episode is from before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit, so we treat it as a supporting voice.)
What the form says
Here is what none of them were handed a briefing on. Every enlistment comes with a DD Form 4, the enlistment document. Section B has a line on promises, and it is printed in capital letters on the form: “The agreements in this section and attached annex(es) are all the promises made to me by the Government. ANYTHING ELSE ANYONE HAS PROMISED ME IS NOT VALID AND WILL NOT BE HONORED.” The same point is repeated above the enlistee’s signature, and again in the service representative’s certification that he explained it. You can read the form itself from the Department of Defense.
We are not telling anyone what to do with that. We are noting what the eight describe. D’Angelo and Sarah describe promises that, on their account, were made out loud. Riggs and Brooks describe a job that was not there when they arrived. Parkes and Haines describe a pitch that was never a promise at all. Brenner describes a recruiter who did right by him. Between them, that is every kind. The only thing they have in common is a signature.
Where to go from here
No advice from us. These are places that exist, what each one does and how to reach it.
- Military OneSource A military service with a 24-hour phone line, 800-342-9647, and confidential help with questions about military life. Its site links to who is eligible.
- Nevada Department of Veterans Services (Las Vegas office) The state agency for Veterans. It helps with VA claims and connects Veterans and families to education, housing, employment and health care benefits.
- Las Vegas Vet Center A VA counseling center, separate from the hospital. Free, confidential individual, group, couples and family counseling. The national Vet Center line is 877-927-8387.
A listing is not an endorsement.
Related questions
If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.
Go hear them say it
Every quote above links to the second it was said, on YouTube. Start with D’Angelo. He tells it better than we do. And if you are in Southern Nevada and want to find your people, our list of posts, clubs and teams is at Veteran resources in Las Vegas.
Stories quoted in this article
- Why Do Marines Treat Dark Humor Like Therapy? Michael D’Angelo USMC 0331
- Every Veteran Is On Their Own After the Uniform. Doc and the MIC Founder Prove That's a Lie.
- Why SERE Breaks People | Marine Recon Instructor Explains Survival Training
- Every Marine Defends Their Boot Camp. He's One of the Few Who Saw Both. / Randall Parkes USMC
- He Listened for 20 Years. Now He Tapes Ankles at a High School.
- Cheeks on Set: From Barracks to Behind the Camera
- Purple Heart Marine Survived IED. Losing His Combat Dog Was Worse. | Alfred Brenner USMC
- Vegas Brunch Just Got EFFIN Crazy - Meet The Woman Behind The Yolk (recorded before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit)