Which military branch should I join?
A $10,000 bonus lost to an eagle, globe and anchor. A jacket on the shoulders. A GED waiting list. Eleven Veterans on how they really picked a branch, and not one of them used a chart.
By Vegas Veteran Voices,
From Every Marine Defends Their Boot Camp. He's One of the Few Who Saw Both. / Randall Parkes USMC
Two Veterans told us nearly the same story from opposite ends.
Randall Parkes was seventeen with a $10,000 Army bonus on the table and a Marine Corps recruiter in front of him, and he chose the Marines. Curtez Riggs was seventeen in a Marine Corps recruiting office with a recruiter’s jacket on his shoulders, and he laughed himself out the door and into the Army. Same decision, same age. Opposite branch.
Neither of them looked at the pay scale. Neither of them read the mission statements. The honest answer to “which branch should I join” is that most of the Veterans we have filmed did not pick a branch. They picked an office. This is what that looks like, eleven times.
The two who walked out
Randall Parkes is a Marine Corps Veteran, drill instructor and founding MARSOC Raider. His grandfather, an Army Veteran, gave him one piece of advice.
“Talk to the other services, just kind of keep your eyes open.”
He did. The Army made an offer.
“We’ll give you your actual MOS, and we’ll give you a $10,000 signing bonus.”
It was the year 2000, and for a seventeen-year-old that was real money. He went back to his Marine recruiter to see if the Marines would match it. The Marine did not negotiate.
“He points to the eagle, globe and anchor and he’s like, ‘Look, man, this is all I can give you.’”
The line that follows is not printable here. It worked. Parkes calls it the most Marine Corps thing ever and says the mind games start right there.
Curtez Riggs, a retired Army First Sergeant and founder of Military Influencer Conference, got the Marine version of that pitch in person. The recruiter took off his jacket, put it on Riggs, turned him to the mirror and asked if he felt like a man.
“I chucked that jacket off and me and my cousin laughed out of the recruiting station.”
He says that incident is what drove him to the Army office, where the approach was gentler. He signed with the Army, served 21 years and retired in 2018.
One recruiter’s marketing is another recruiter’s gift. That is the whole lesson, and it will keep.
The ones a waiting list picked
Michael D’Angelo, a Marine Corps Veteran, machine gunner and stand-up comic, left high school in the middle of his junior year, got a GED and walked into the Navy office. The Navy had news.
“We’re not accepting GEDs right now, though. We’ll have to put you on a waiting list.”
He had just left high school for this. The Navy recruiters had a suggestion.
“Well, the Marine Corps office is right there.”
Jason Brooks, a medically retired Marine and former Recon and SERE instructor, took a longer route to the same lobby. He went to the Air Force first, because he wanted to be a pararescueman.
“Before I joined the Marine Corps, believe it or not, I went to go join the Air Force because I wanted to go PJ.”
His past needed waivers, and the Air Force told him that meant taking whatever it needed that year, which was aircraft mechanic. No deal on PJ tryouts. He walked, and the Marines took him.
The ones who followed a friend, a movie or a cartoon
This is the biggest group.
Caitlin Duffy, a U.S. Army Veteran, 50 cal gunner and now a VA loan specialist, was a junior in high school who did not want college. Two classmates had a plan for the afternoon.
“Hey, we’re going to the recruiting office. We’re going to go and join the army. You want to go?”
Her answer was “sure”. She says she would do it again a million times over.
Nate Rosas, a U.S. Army Veteran, was a high school freshman on 9/11 and says a lot of his friends were going Army. He tried the Air Force too, and the recruiters were never in the office.
“I remember I actually tried to join the Air Force but they were never there.”
(Rosas’s episode is from before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit, so we treat it as a supporting voice.)
Edward Haines, a retired Marine Master Sergeant, picked his branch in about first grade.
“I want to say it was GI Joe cartoon, if you want the truth.”
His father, a Marine Reservist, finished the job.
“My dad’s like, ‘It’s hard. Not everybody can make it.’”
He says he answered: I’ll show you. Then the recruiter called, and he adds a message for Marine recruiters reading this. Your phone calls work.
“Cheeks” Aguillon, a U.S. Army Veteran and former chaplain assistant who now serves on the Vegas Veteran Voices board, picked the Army because family had.
“Both my grandpas were in the military, were in the army.”
One of them was a paratrooper in the 11th Airborne. He was the kid who wore combat pants to high school and blousing his boots. The branch was settled long before he met a recruiter.
Emilio Mackie, a U.S. Navy Veteran and surface warfare officer, picked the Navy for a movie.
“I grew up watching Top Gun as a kid and it was super cool seeing the fighter jets and ships.”
He says his parents shook him by the shoulders and said he was going to college first. He went through Naval ROTC at the University of Arizona and commissioned in 2020, on Zoom.
The one who walked in by accident
Chelsey Gray, a U.S. Marine Corps Veteran and parachute rigger, was being recruited by the Army. She wanted the hardest thing she could find, and she did not know the difference in the uniforms.
“And so I walked into the Marine Corps office on accident.”
She says she did not intentionally try to join the Marine Corps. That is as close to a branch comparison as anyone in this article gets.
Where you land is another question
Here is the part that nobody’s recruiter mentions. Picking the branch is the first of two decisions, and the second one is not yours.
Bobi Pike-Oates, a retired Air Force Senior Master Sergeant, wanted to be a city cop. In the 1970s the height rule was 5’7” or 5’8”, and she was 5’3”. A friend who had done four years in the Air Force offered a suggestion.
“A state trooper friend of mine had spent four years in the Air Force and said, ‘Why don’t you join the Air Force?’”
She backed out of the recruiter’s office the first time and went back the second. Then she got the job.
“My maintenance scores were my lowest scores, but that’s when they were putting gals into maintenance, so it didn’t matter.”
She built a career in aircraft maintenance. Her first assignment was a Spanish base, where she worked heavy maintenance on F-4s a year after Franco died.
So the best-informed branch choice in this article ended with the Air Force assigning her a job her test scores said she would be worst at, because the Air Force had a place to put her.
What they agree on, and do not
They do not agree on a branch. Parkes does not tell you the Marines are better than the Army, and Riggs does not tell you the opposite. Gray does not tell you the Marines are the hardest branch; she says she wanted the hardest thing she could find and walked into the wrong building, or the right one.
What they do agree on is quieter. You are choosing a recruiter, a culture and an enlistment contract all at once, and the first of those is the only one you can see from the parking lot. The pitch that works on one seventeen-year-old makes another one laugh at the recruiter. Neither is wrong.
Where to go from here
No advice from us. These are places that exist, what each one does and how to reach it.
- Military OneSource A military service with a 24-hour phone line, 800-342-9647, and confidential help with questions about military life. Its site links to who is eligible.
- VA: About GI Bill benefits VA's overview of its education programs, which help eligible Veterans and family members cover school or job training and some living expenses.
- Nevada Department of Veterans Services (Las Vegas office) The state agency for Veterans. It helps with VA claims and connects Veterans and families to education, housing, employment and health care benefits.
A listing is not an endorsement.
Related questions
If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.
Go hear them say it
Every quote above links to the second it was said, on YouTube. Start with Parkes if you want the funniest recruiter story, or Riggs if you want the one with a lesson. And if you are in Southern Nevada, our list of posts, clubs and teams is at Veteran resources in Las Vegas.
Stories quoted in this article
- Every Marine Defends Their Boot Camp. He's One of the Few Who Saw Both. / Randall Parkes USMC
- Every Veteran Is On Their Own After the Uniform. Doc and the MIC Founder Prove That's a Lie.
- Why SERE Breaks People | Marine Recon Instructor Explains Survival Training
- She Paved The Way For Women In The Air Force | Bobi Pike-Oates | US Military
- Why Do Marines Treat Dark Humor Like Therapy? Michael D’Angelo USMC 0331
- He Listened for 20 Years. Now He Tapes Ankles at a High School.
- Every Marine Calls It a Brotherhood. She's Finally Saying What Hers Did. / Chelsey Gray
- Aboard a Submarine: What No One Tells You About Life After Service
- Cheeks on Set: From Barracks to Behind the Camera
- From 50 Cal Gunner to VA Loan Nerd | Caitlin Duffy’s Veteran Story
- How Hockey Is Giving Veterans a Second Chapter / Really OK Hockey / Las Vegas Warriors @ Able Baker (recorded before Vegas Veteran Voices became a nonprofit)