A frame from the story “Who Is the Man Behind Terminal Lance?”

Veterans Say

Why don't Veterans talk about their service?

Strangers ask the wrong question. Families do not ask at all. Eight people on why the stories stay put, and what finally got them out.

By Vegas Veteran Voices,

From Who Is the Man Behind Terminal Lance?

Ask a Veteran about their service and one of two things happens. You get a one-line answer that closes the topic, or you get a story you did not expect, told in a voice you have never heard them use. The difference is usually the question.

In interviews filmed by Vegas Veteran Voices, a Las Vegas nonprofit, eight people told us why the stories stay put. A few of them also told us what got the story out. They do not agree on whether Veterans should talk more. They agree on what the wrong question sounds like.

The question that worked

Maximilian Uriarte, a Marine Corps infantry Veteran and the creator of Terminal Lance, remembers a dinner with a girlfriend’s family after he got out. An aunt he had never met asked him about his life. He talked about the Marine Corps and Iraq. She asked one question back.

“That was the only question she asked me.”

Hear it at 21:05

The question was what did you learn. He says it took him back.

“It was such a deep question. It took me back.”

Hear it at 21:13

He was writing his book, The White Donkey, at the time. It is a fictional narrative, he says, because it is not word for word anything that happened.

“This was my way of sort of distilling that whole experience down into the true core of what I took away from it.”

Hear it at 22:25

Not every question lands like that one. Nate Rosas, a U.S. Army Veteran who served in Afghanistan and plays Veterans hockey, has heard the other kind. His interview comes from before our nonprofit started, so we give it as supporting.

“When I tell people I’m a vet, one of the first thing they ask me as a civilian that has no clue what’s going on with Veterans is, ‘How many people have you killed?’”

Hear it at 6:02

He says it shows how little people understand about the range of jobs in the military. You can see why someone who has heard it a few times answers with one line.

Nothing to say, or so it feels

Some Veterans stay quiet because they think they have nothing to tell. JMach, a Marine Corps Veteran and host of the JMach Podcast, says it plainly.

“I myself have no combat experience, never been deployed, anything like that.”

Hear it at 38:31

He says he still felt connected to Veterans with combat stories when he watched a documentary about them. For more on how it feels to carry that, see Am I a real Veteran if I never deployed?.

AJ Kehl, a U.S. Air Force Veteran and career firefighter, says the same doubt shows up when a Veteran thinks their trouble is too small to count.

“Everyone has it worse and better than you. But that doesn’t mean that you’re not important and that you didn’t serve.”

Hear it at 44:01

The older generation

Kehl puts a date on the habit. He is talking to Veterans who answer a doctor’s question with a shrug.

“Not just, ‘I’m okay, everything’s fine,’ because you don’t want to talk about it. That’s the older generation.”

Hear it at 45:21

Rosas says it is not only older Veterans. He says his own generation does the same.

“I didn’t have any idea they were Veterans just because we weren’t talking about it.”

Hear it at 1:03:21

He had skated with some of the same men for years. When he joined Veterans hockey, they found out.

“I had been skating and I’ve known you for years. We just don’t talk about that.”

Hear it at 1:03:37

What families see

Gretchen Catherwood is a Gold Star mother and the founder of Darkhorse Lodge, a retreat for combat Veterans in Tennessee. She is not a Veteran. She watched her husband come home from Desert Storm.

“I knew that there were so many things he couldn’t talk to me about.”

Hear it at 6:04

She tells of a dinner after a memorial ceremony. She and her daughter stood back while Marines talked in a parking lot, and one said something she has not forgotten.

“This is the first time I’ve been able to talk about that day.”

Hear it at 6:51

That day was the day her son and another Marine died. She says it was when she decided to build the lodge.

Nikki Kraus, a U.S. Air Force Veteran and weather forecaster, has her own version. She wrote a book, and her mother learned from it what she had never been told. The book opens with the worst night of a hard period.

“Dude, you didn’t tell me about this.”

Hear it at 25:51

The ones who talk too much

Not everyone is quiet. Caitlin Duffy, a U.S. Army Veteran and 50 cal gunner who is now a VA loan specialist, says some Veterans lead with it for years.

“They’ve been out for four years and them being a Veteran is the first thing out of their mind or first thing out of their mouth.”

Hear it at 35:06

So there are at least three different silences here. The Veteran who has been asked the wrong thing, the Veteran who feels they have nothing worth telling, and the one who was raised not to.

How some of them got it out

Jason Lee Morrison, a Marine Corps Veteran from Recon, a writer and a poet, says what writing did.

“I had to study my own life, be a student of it, and then write it down and read what I’d written down.”

Hear it at 34:04

He says it is a lot when you are writing down your own mistakes. Uriarte’s book and Kraus’s book say the same thing in different ways. Writing it down, for them, was the way to say it.

The Library of Congress runs the Veterans History Project, created by Congress in 2000 to collect and keep Veterans’ own accounts. It takes recorded interviews, memoirs, letters and photographs, and asks that the Veteran and the interviewer sign release forms.

Where to go from here

No advice from us. These are places that exist, what each one does and how to reach it.

  • Library of Congress Veterans History Project A Congress-created project that collects and keeps Veterans' own accounts, mainly recorded interviews, along with memoirs, letters and photographs. Participation requires signed release forms.
  • Las Vegas Vet Center A VA counseling center that is separate from the hospital. Free, confidential individual and group counseling. 702-791-9170.
  • Team Red, White & Blue, Las Vegas chapter The Las Vegas chapter of the national nonprofit that connects Veterans through fitness and social events.
  • Vet Center call center The Vet Center program's national phone line, answered around the clock. 877-927-8387.

A listing is not an endorsement.

Related questions

If you are a Veteran in crisis or having thoughts of suicide, call 988 and press 1, or text 838255. The Veterans Crisis Line is free and confidential, 24 hours a day.

Go hear them say it

Every quote above links to the second it was said. If you want the stories as they were told, they are on our YouTube channel, and our list of local places is at Veteran resources in Las Vegas.

Stories quoted in this article

DonateFund the next story